Here is a compilation of every starting pitcher who finished with an ERA under 3.50 and WHIP under 1.30 in 2012:

-Jerrod Parker
-Matt Harrison
-Jeremy Hellickson
-Brandon McCarthy
-Jason Hammel
-Ryan Vogelsong
-Ross Detwiler
-Bartolo Colon
-Miguel Gonzalez
-Ryan Dempster
-Zack Greinke
-Doug Fister
-Wade Miley
-Jonathon Niese
-Jordan Zimmerman
-Hiroki Kuroda
-Mat Latos
-Stephen Strasburg
-Feliz Hernandez
-CC Sabathia
-Chris Sale
-A.J. Griffin
-Gio Gonzalez
-Cole Hamels
-Brandon Morrow
-Cliff Lee
-Madison Bumgarner
-David Price
-Jake Peavy
-Kyle Lohse
-Justin Verlander
-R.A. Dickey
-Chris Tillman
-Matt Cain
-Clayton Kershaw
-Jered Weaver
-Brandon Beachy
-Kris Medlen

A lot of these snarfs will still be available in the later rounds of your fantasy baseball draft. I scoured up several myself.